One significant outcome of the recent midterms in the US is the victory of a record number of candidates with socialist credentials. Six ‘Democratic Socialists’ returned to the House of Representatives, raising their strength to eight. Earlier in 2025, Zohran Mamdani, also a democratic socialist, was elected as the New York City Mayor.
Do these back-to-back victories mean socialism is finally on the rise in the country better known as the paterfamilias of capitalism and may, a few decades down the road, become a credible alternative to the erstwhile system?
While one may be tempted to answer this question in the affirmative, it seems plausible that, more than signalling the growing strength of socialism in the US, such developments bring out the inherent virility of capitalism. Why? The answer consists in the most potent symbol of Chinese civilisation – Yin-Yang.
Originating in the ancient Chinese school of Taoism, the Yin-Yang is represented by a circle consisting of two parts: a black portion encapsulating a white dot called Yin and a white portion containing a black dot, which is known as Yang. The Yin-Yang dialectically describes how, in both natural and social orders, opposite forces – life and death, day and night, strength and weakness, the negative and the positive – need and balance each other.
One classic validation of the Yin-Yang philosophy is the resounding success of China’s own development model. Starting in the early 1980s, the People’s Republic of China overcame the state-market contradiction by adopting the philosophy of ‘Socialism with Chinese Characteristics.’ Under paramount leader Deng Xiaoping and later his successor Jiang Zemin, a closed socialist economy was gradually and carefully opened to market forces and foreign competition without giving up iron-clad state control. The experiment has been a spectacular success, converting an agrarian economy into an industrial powerhouse, while the Communist Party of China (CPC) continues to hold all the aces.
This makes Socialism with Chinese Characteristics, which adroitly blends the contradictory systems of socialism and capitalism, one of the most powerful political philosophies of all time. In the last decade, the current Chinese paramount leader, Xi Jinping, made some tweaks to this philosophy to match changing conditions and renamed it ‘Socialism with Chinese Characteristics for a New Era.’
An equally potent validation of the Yin-Yang philosophy is the ascendancy of capitalism in the 19th and 20th centuries, and its continuation today. Capitalism took birth in England in the second half of the 18th century before spreading to continental Europe. The intellectual basis of capitalism rested on laissez-faire, literally translated as ‘leave us alone.’
The essential argument was that freedom meant the absence of legal restraints and that law and liberty were mutually incompatible. Any government intervention in the economy makes things worse. Left to themselves, market forces have the capacity to produce an optimal outcome in the long run.
One implication of the creed-like trust in market mechanisms was the labour theory of value. If workers draw subsistence wages, they must be putting in low value or effort as well. Hence, the fault lies with them and not with the system. Government intervention in the form of a minimum wage will only increase the number of unemployed people. By the same token, if capitalists multiply their fortunes, they deserve it, because it’s the fruit of their risk-taking.
When applied to industry, the laissez-faire doctrine ushered in horrid working conditions, with the government keeping its hands off in the name of freedom of contract. A powerful insight into worker exploitation has been given in Charles Dickens’ novels. The situation forced subsequent liberal thinkers to concede a more active role for the government in the interest of society, but more than that, in the interest of capitalism itself.
This was done through pro-worker legislation, such as the Factories Act of 1847 (fixing maximum working hours), and the Trade Union Act of 1871 (giving the right to collective bargaining). Such regulations ratcheted down discontent with capitalism in England and elsewhere in industrial Europe. Thus, capitalism took a human face without abandoning its essential philosophy.
The pro-worker measures continued into the 20th century to keep socialism and its extreme variety, communism, at bay. The most notable of such measures was the rise of the welfare state in Western Europe. Another related development of comparable significance was the rise of centre-left social democratic parties including the Labour Party in England, the Social Democratic Party of Germany, the Socialist Party in France, and the Swedish Social Democratic Party. The manifestos and programmes of such parties represented a synthesis of a capitalist economy, labour rights and social safety nets. The electoral successes of those parties shut the doors on a socialist revolution in Western Europe and ensured that capitalism would remain alive and kicking.
Historically and doctrinally (the right to choose), capitalism has gone hand in hand with multiparty democracy. Hence, when, in the late 1980s, Soviet leader Mikhail Gorbachev set about restructuring the socialist economy, his American counterparts advised him to open up the authoritarian political system as well. He agreed and ended up breaking up the USSR. Once the communist threat had fizzled out, capitalism dumped the welfare state and contrived neoliberalism, which essentially represented the resurgence of laissez-faire capitalism; without it, the rise of Big Tech in the US wouldn’t have happened.
Contrary to Western Europe, socialism has never even come close to getting a foothold in the US. Of the two principal political players, the Democratic Party is more inclined towards socialism or the centre-left than the Republicans. Demographically, socialism is more popular among the youth than among other age groups – and understandably so. There’s also the Communist Party of the USA (CPUSA), founded in 1919 and committed to establishing socialism in the country. The party is currently struggling for survival, having faced a split in 1924.
The most notable centre-left group in the US is the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA). Founded in 1982, the DSA seeks to expand public ownership of enterprises and beef up social safety nets, such as Medicare for All and the protection of labour rights. The DSA itself doesn’t field candidates for public office, preferring to support left-leaning ones. By the end of 2025, more than 250 DSA-supported people held elected public office across the country, most notably New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani. Senator Bernie Sanders, who made unsuccessful runs for the Democratic Party’s presidential nomination in 2016 and 2020, also describes himself as a democratic socialist.
Over decades, capitalism, with no small help from multiparty democracy, has shown a remarkable capacity to adapt itself to the changing circumstances and respond to the new challenges without compromising on its essential doctrine of giving full play to the market forces as the final arbiter of production, distribution and consumption decisions in an economy. Inherently anti-worker, capitalism has always responded to the challenges by incorporating some elements of its adversary – ultimately conquering it. In the American context as well, capitalism will be willing to assume whatever human face is necessary, only to take off the mask when it’s no longer required.
If history is any guide, capitalism can’t be weakened, much less dethroned, by social or pro-worker legislation. Only a big push can bring it down. But let’s not spoil the Democratic Socialists Party.
The writer is an Islamabad-based columnist. He tweets/posts @hussainhzaidi and can be reached at: [email protected]
Disclaimer: The viewpoints expressed in this piece are the writer’s own and don’t necessarily reflect Geo.tv’s editorial policy.
Originally published in The News
