Alexis Stucky, Kennedy Martin and volleyball’s riskiest reunion
0 22 mins 2 hrs


ALEXIS STUCKY CAN’T look Kennedy Martin in the eye.

It’s a scorching September 2024 day in Gainesville, Florida, and her Gators volleyball team is down 2-1 against archrival Kentucky. The fourth set is tied at 28-28. If they lose the next point, it’s match point Kentucky.

The redshirt sophomore setter, who had sat out most of the previous season after tearing her ACL and MCL, stands in a huddle next to Martin, the Gators’ 6-foot-6 dominant opposite hitter. Stucky feels Martin applying pressure to her shoulder the way Martin always does. It’s her “we got this” touch.

But Stucky doesn’t believe her. She doesn’t believe in herself.

Stucky takes her spot in the back row and receives a perfect pass to run the offense. Martin is available on Stucky’s right side, eager to take a rip.

“Everyone and their mother knows that the ball should go to Ken,” Stucky says.

I can’t do it.

I can’t set Ken.

I’m gonna mess it up.

Stucky’s brain won’t stop chirping.

Stop. Go away.

Stucky jumps, her arms outstretched, her red hair in a halo around her head. Expecting the ball, Martin begins her approach.

Stucky sets the ball to the left side instead. To Isabel Martin, who hits it over but not down.

Kennedy lands and turns around to look at Stucky. Stucky stares straight ahead. In the corner of her eye, she notices multiple Gators coaches gesturing, “What is wrong with you?”

I know.

Trust me, I know.

Stucky watches Kentucky star Brooklyn DeLeye jump and slam the ball down. There’s nothing the Gators can do.

Match point Kentucky.

DeLeye dribbles the ball to the service line.

Stucky stares straight ahead.

The ball floats toward the Florida passers. Stucky doesn’t even move.

Ace.

Kentucky wins.

Stucky runs to get in the team huddle. She still can’t make eye contact with Martin.

“I was so anxious about setting Ken, I was so anxious about ruining the play that I just set someone else because I thought it would be an automatic error if I set Ken,” Stucky says. “I just could not set her.

“I would not set her.”

Part of it was mental. Martin was an All-American-in-waiting and Stucky wanted badly — soooo badly — for everything to be perfect. If a Martin swing resulted in anything other than a kill, Stucky was convinced it was her fault. Another part of it was physical. Setting a player who stands 78 inches is rare. Setting a player whose outstretched arm reaches some 100 inches is rarer still. Setting a player who leaps high enough to dunk a basketball? Yeah. Martin is different. Add to that the fact that Stucky was fresh off a major knee injury and the complexity of the situation becomes clear.

It got so bad that when Martin, a first-team All-American, announced after the season that she was transferring, Stucky felt sweet, sweet relief.

“Obviously, you never want Kennedy Martin to leave your team,” Stucky says, laughing nervously. “But, for my own [sake], I thought maybe I’m going to be OK.”


MARTIN STARES AT STUCKY as that last sentence lands. She opens her mouth and then closes it. As if she wants to say something, but words are escaping her. She shakes her head.

It’s a hot June day, months before the start of the 2026 NCAA volleyball season and nearly 1,000 miles north of Gainesville. Stucky and Martin sit across from me at a high-top table at The Field, their favorite burger spot in State College, Pennsylvania. Martin’s “Juicy Lucy” — their signature wagyu burger — sits in front of her, untouched for the past few minutes.

Mid-chew, Stucky explains to me — and apparently to Martin — that she still feels the lingering effects of that anxiety, even now as they prepare to run it back as teammates at Penn State.

“It’s still in the back of my mind,” Stucky says as she pauses.

“All the time.”

“If I mis-set her, like, two balls in a row, I’m like, ‘Oh my god,'” she says.

After a long pause, burger still intact on her plate, Martin arches her eyebrows and says to me, “I didn’t know she felt like that.”

“I have been calling everyone and telling them that we picked up right back where we left off, so…” she says as her voice trails off. She looks off to the side.

That doesn’t make sense, I prod her. Even if she didn’t pick up on the severity, there’s no way she didn’t know Stucky was struggling in 2024, I say.

Martin shakes her head. She meant all the way back, to 2023, the first season they played together. Before Stucky’s season-ending injury. Before the anxiety. Before the missed connections and missed opportunities. Before they went their separate ways. Before they knew they’d get a second chance in a new place in 2026, first for an inaugural Big Ten tournament title and then for the NCAA championship that once seemed so attainable but has proved so elusive in the years and disappointment since.


BACK IN 2023, Martin was a freshman at Florida and Stucky was returning for her second season. Florida coach Mary Wise took one look at the duo — and the rest of her team — and knew there was something special.

“It’s a team that honestly, we looked like this could be it,” Wise says. “This team could win it all.”

That first month, Martin and Stucky felt as if they could do no wrong. Stucky made intense eye contact with Martin, who returned it with the same fervor. In the air their movements were as coordinated and graceful as dragonflies, Stucky setting the ball perfectly for Martin to pummel downward.

In their first match together — against Penn State — Martin had a team-high 18 kills and Stucky dished 55 assists. Next time out, Martin pummeled 27. And so it went. Assist after assist for Stucky and kill after kill for Martin. Florida won its first eight regular-season matches, rolling by three teams ranked in the top 10, and was ranked No. 3 in the nation.

Then, “It was like I died,” Stucky says.

In front of a record home crowd of 10,323 fans against No. 1 Wisconsin, Florida cruised to a 25-15 win in the first set. No sweat. The Gators were leading 14-13 in the second set when Stucky jumped for a tight pass and dumped the ball over the net. She landed awkwardly on her right leg.

“It was a freak play,” she says.

At first she thought she was cramping. Martin didn’t even know anything was off. Then Stucky’s knee buckled. A sharp pain. Tears pricked her eyes. “Get me out of here,” she said to her coaching staff. She couldn’t sob in front of all these fans.

Inside the locker room, the team doctor walked in. Stucky knew.

“It’s your ACL,” he said. They scheduled an MRI for the next day. Stucky watched as Florida’s backup setter, Kennedy Muff, valiantly tried to close the win. The Gators lost a grueling five-setter.

The next day, the MRI revealed that Stucky had torn her ACL, MCL and meniscus. She chipped a little piece of her femur and messed up all of her tendons.

“Like, I blew the whole thing out, just jumping and landing on one foot,” she says.

As Stucky went through surgery, rest and months of rehab, Martin felt purposeless the rest of the 2023 season. Without Stucky, Florida’s national title hopes disappeared. They went 10-8 before losing in the second round of the NCAA tournament to Georgia Tech. Martin played in all 29 matches and finished with 492 kills. It was not nearly enough.

She decided to erase the second half of the season — starting with Stucky’s injury — from her memory.

2024 will be our year.


KENNEDY MARTIN ARRIVED at the O’Dome on a Friday in September 2024 like a jack-in-the box on the song’s final note. A long 369 days had come and gone since she last played a match with Stucky. The streak would end on this day.

Stucky was a ball of anxiety. Yes, she was cleared to play. And yes she would have two matches before the intense SEC schedule began, but her body still had to relearn how to play the sport she loved. That much had become obvious in her practices leading up to this Sept. 20 match.

“I was fine enough to play volleyball,” Stucky says. “But I wasn’t good at volleyball.”

She used to feel lithe when she jumped. Now she felt like a troll. Her brain churned “what if” questions at her. What if you hurt yourself again? What if you tear your ACL and MCL again? What if, what if, what if?

Certain positions felt agonizing. Her body essentially forgot how to back set. To make matters worse, more than half of Florida’s offense that season went through Martin, which often required Stucky to back set.

“So any time I did set her and she didn’t score, I had this overwhelming anxiety that I wasn’t helping the team, at all,” Stucky says. “Like, if I can’t set Ken, what am I doing out here?”

Wise told Stucky to give it time — “she’s not the most patient person in the room” — and that slowly things would click.

They did. Somewhat. It wasn’t always pretty, but Martin finished the season with 512 kills and led the nation by scoring 6.28 points per set. The Gators were swept in two of their next three matches following that Kentucky loss when Stucky could not — would not — set Martin. Florida dropped its final two regular-season matches heading into the NCAA tournament. When Florida fell to Stanford in the regional semifinal, part of Stucky was glad to be free of her misery.

She spent days and weeks pondering the idea of transferring. She told herself she wasn’t good enough to be at Florida, to be setting Martin. She convinced herself that she needed to go to a small program. And learn to play the sport again.

Martin started showing up at Stucky’s house trying to convince her that 2025 would be better. That she needed to give herself time and grace.

Eventually, Stucky gave in. But in a series of plot twists, it was Martin who decided to go.

Wise announced her retirement in February 2025 after 34 seasons and 987 wins at Florida. Rather than promoting associate head coach Dave Boos, Florida hired a new coach from Marquette named Ryan Theis. The vibe in the gym was different. Martin had committed to Wise, and here was a new coach who didn’t know her and whose approach wasn’t working for her.

She reached out to two people: first, a phone call to Wise to thank her for everything she’d done for her. And then in a car ride around campus, she apologized to Stucky. When she convinced Stucky to stay, leaving was the last thing on her mind. Now Martin knew she needed to go.

More than 200 coaches reached out. Penn State’s rich tradition and coach Katie Schumacher-Cawley’s approach intrigued Martin most. She chose Penn State.

When Stucky and Martin hugged goodbye, sadness mixed with excitement. A fresh start awaited Martin at Penn State. Stucky could focus on herself, instead of living in anxiety of not being a good enough setter for Martin.


MARTIN WALKED INTO Rec Hall, and felt giddy as she took in the program’s history. The Nittany Lions’ “NCAA Champions” banner recently had been updated to reflect the 2024 national championship, the team’s eighth. Martin would get to help them defend the national title. She imagined holding the trophy.

At practice, the temperature in the gym was turned up to 84 degrees (exactly), a Penn State tradition that has been upheld for decades. The discomfort, they believed, would set them up for success. Martin felt energized.

That warm, fuzzy feeling barely made it to September. Penn State won its first two matches. Lost its next two. And then setter Izzy Starck, who had led Penn State to the championship the previous season, left the team, citing her mental health.

Am I cursed? Martin remembers thinking. Two years before, when she felt similar excitement, Stucky blew out her knee. Now another setter was gone?

Martin tried to recalibrate, but Penn State finished the season 19-13 after losing to Texas in the second round of the NCAA tournament.

Back in Gainesville, as spring of 2025 rolled into summer, Stucky’s game started to return. She could jump without feeling the heaviness of her body. She moved faster. She lifted heavy in the gym. Her back set, which gave her nightmares the previous season, began to consistently hit its mark.

In October, she recorded a rare triple-double — 42 assists, 10 kills and 12 digs — against Auburn. But Florida’s tournament run also ended in the second round, to SMU. Still, Stucky considered the season a win: She started in all 28 matches and her progress was palpable. It was time to move on.

“I promised Florida I would be there for four years, and I was there for four years. I got my degree,” Stucky says. “I just felt like I had run my course there.”

Even before the season ended, Stucky had been wondering about her next step. She had a year of eligibility left and she felt as if she could contribute to a contender.

One day in November, Martin was on the phone with Stucky’s roommate — a Florida soccer player — which eventually, as it often did, became a group call. That’s when Martin hollered an idea, purely as a joke, at Stucky.

“You know, if you have any interest,” she said. “We have a setter position open.”

Martin thought Stucky would laugh it off. Instead she saw Stucky pause.

“Let’s talk about this in December,” Stucky said.


SCHUMACHER-CAWLEY KNEW nothing about Stucky’s baggage with Martin when she saw her name in the transfer portal. She immediately thought, “She’s a competitor. We need her.”

To Martin, the calculus was simple: Penn State needed a setter. A good one. A healthy Stucky would be a great one. When Schumacher-Cawley asked for her opinion, Martin told her to go get her.

To Stucky, it came down to this: Yes, it ended badly the last time they played together. But they’re different people now. Time healed her and made her more confident. Time made Martin forget the little she remembered. What if it all goes well?

As soon as Stucky committed, they decided to move in together. In some ways they felt as if they had been living and playing together all this while. In other ways, going on hikes around campus, walking to Rec Hall for practice felt new.

Stucky had a “built-in best friend” on the team, and the transition felt easy. It helped that she vibed immediately with Schumacher-Cawley’s coaching tactics. At Florida, hitters tipped the ball a lot. That made Stucky question her setting skills. At Penn State, hitters swung at every ball. It boosted her confidence.

“[Schumacher-Cawley] talked to me a lot about, like, throwing my shoulders back and playing with swag and confidence, and being like, ‘I am really good at my job, act like it,'” Stucky says.

In Stucky’s first weeks at Penn State, Schumacher-Cawley noticed that she was being tentative, particularly while back setting Martin. “She knows what a special player Kennedy is, that she wants it to be perfect for her,” Schumacher-Cawley says. “She was hurting herself for sure.”

As the season progressed, Stucky became a better player defensively, and Schumacher-Cawley began to notice that one or two errors in setting Martin did not shake her in the same way.

The day before a Halloween showdown vs. No. 11 Purdue, Schumacher-Cawley praised the duo’s progress but said the two have a “huge test” ahead of them, first at home against Purdue and then on the road against Minnesota and Wisconsin.

Stucky and Martin passed.

In a sea of red, Penn State shared two sets apiece with No. 7 Wisconsin. With the Nittany Lions ahead 14-11 in the fifth set, Wisconsin’s freshman hitter Decelise Champion slammed the ball toward Penn State. Ava Falduto set up a pass for Stucky.

Stucky didn’t look at Martin, who was to her right. She didn’t need to. She knew exactly where Martin was.

She set the ball high. Martin jumped and swung. Hard. The ball slammed into the Wisconsin block and rolled off out of bounds on Penn State’s side. Martin turned toward Stucky. They made eye contact. She slammed her chest into Stucky’s. They ran to the huddle. It was Penn State’s sixth straight win against a ranked opponent. Now, they’ve won 10 straight matches to close the regular season and earned the No. 2 seed in the inaugural Big Ten tournament. Martin had 207 kills and hit an unfathomable .388 during that stretch. On Thursday, she was named the Big Ten Player of the Year.


SITTING NEXT TO MARTIN in their hotel lobby across from Wrigley Field, hours before a September match against Kentucky, Stucky tells me it’s rare to get a second chance, to finish their story the way they wanted to.

Martin tells me how important it is to peak at the right time. They want to play the best volleyball leading into the Big Ten tournament beginning Friday. Right in time for the NCAA tournament.

Martin turns to Stucky and nudges her to share what they talked about during a recent practice.

Stucky recalls the phrase she said to her in front of the team after practice. “I’m glad that we had our years at Florida together, because otherwise I wouldn’t understand you at all.”

In what way, I ask them.

“She truly just will forget things, and things don’t bother her. She moves on from them really quickly,” Stucky says. “That’s not a normal trait in a lot of people.”

Right now, Stucky is worried about how the wind is going to affect her sets on the baseball field later that day. Martin? She hasn’t thought about the wind once.

But Stucky knows exactly how to navigate Martin’s brain. And, she believes in herself now, she says.

They lock eyes. They both grin. They decide to walk to a nearby sandwich shop for lunch before warmups.

“This,” Martin says, “is going to work.”



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *